Mother wins appeal in suspected abuse case
In Re H-L, the 19 year-old mother had given birth to a child with a rare genetic disorder which resulted in malformation of her spine. She initially coped well with her daughter’s problems but care proceedings were launched when her nursery noticed bruising on the child which seemed to lack explanation. The girl, now two, now lives with foster carers.
The care proceedings came before a judge at Newcastle County Court in February. During the case the mother applied for permission to seek expert assessments of the girl’s bruising from a geneticist; a haematologist; and a paediatrician. Her application was refused on the grounds that there was no evidence to suggest bruising was a feature of her disability and the application did not, therefore, meet a key requirement of part 25 of the Family Procedure Rules 2010. This states that:
“The court will not direct an expert to attend a hearing unless it is necessary to do so in the interests of justice.”
The mother appealed. In the Court of Appeal, Sir James Munby, who is President of the Family Division, discussed the meaning of the word ‘necessary’ in this context. He said it was an “ordinary English word” and endorsed the definition given in the earlier case of Re P:
“…a meaning lying somewhere between ‘indispensable’ on the one hand and ‘useful’, ‘reasonable’ or ‘desirable’ on the other hand”, having “the connotation of the imperative, what is demanded rather than what is merely optional or reasonable or desirable.”
Meanwhile, Lord Justice McFarlane declared that the unanimous decision of the court was to allow the mother’s appeal in the case of the geneticist. Instruction of the geneticist on a strictly limited basis would provide the court with expert insight into whether the girl’s condition could have resulted in the bruising, which was the central medical question.
The judge said:
“…it is plain to me that that instruction, on those terms, is proportionate to the need to provide some authoritative clarity from a witness who is in a position to give such answers and is therefore “necessary” in the manner that is described more fully in the President’s judgment.”
However, he added:
“So far as the instruction of a haematologist and a paediatrician are concerned, I do not consider that the appeal even begins to get off the ground.”
Photo by John Halbrook via Flickr under a Creative Commons licence
Share this post
Get free family law updates
Marilyn Stowe’s new book: expert advice on all aspects of divorce, just 99p!
Divorce & Splitting Up by Marilyn Stowe is the essential how-to book for anyone who is getting divorced or splitting up from a partner. Read more >>
"A must buy that really opens your eyes to what is involved if you are considering or going through a divorce." - Amanda Brown
"This will answer your questions in a way that non-lawyers can understand." - Miss P.
"Don't get divorced without it. I read this book despite being divorced for more than 10 years. I wish I'd had this book to hand at the time. Great examples, simple to read and understand." - Jamie
"This really has helped me to see that there is light at the end of the tunnel and I will come out of it a stronger person." - J
Marilyn Stowe on SKY News & ITV This Morning
Thought For The Day
- Ray on Applying for the Decree Absolute and what comes next
- Tristan on An unwelcome guest at Christmas by John Bolch
- Yvie on Grandparents should be allowed time off to help with childcare, TUC claims
- Jenny on Delaying the Decree Absolute: another look at Miller Smith v Miller Smith
- Louis on Applying for the Decree Absolute and what comes next
Subscribe & Follow
In the Media
Marilyn Stowe is the senior partner in Stowe Family Law, which has offices in Yorkshire, Cheshire and London. With more than 30 years’ experience handling divorce cases and family law proceedings she is regarded as one of the most formidable and sought after divorce lawyers in the UK. In 2012, Marilyn became one of the first solicitors to qualify as a family law arbitrator.
All persons mentioned in the scenarios are fictitious: details have been deliberately changed in order to protect identities and other confidential circumstances of my clients. All advice and information on this blog including posts written by guest authors, is given only as a general guide to the operation of the law on the date of publication. Readers must place no reliance whatsoever on the content of this blog and must always obtain their own legal advice. Marilyn Stowe, Stowe Family Law LLP and guest authors accept no liability whatsoever arising as a result of reliance upon its content.
Contact Stowe Family Law
These downloads accompany Marilyn Stowe's latest book: Divorce & Splitting Up: Advice From a Top Divorce Lawyer. After opening, right click to save to your computer.
For more free downloads, visit the Downloads section.